Stop the City from abolishing your property rights – action required

Posted on August 5, 2013 · Posted in Development

Sign the Avaaz petition by clicking here.

Email your objections to:

  • The Mayor’s e-mail is –
  • Cllr Beverley Schafer –
  • Cllr Marga Haywood –
  • DA Office –
  • Helen Zille –

Overview on how the City will not take your objections into consideration in the future:

The proposed amendments to the City’s system of delegations for Economic, Environmental and Spatial Planning (EESP) matters, refers. 


The general public are probably not aware that the City Council, in conjunction with the Mayors Office, have proposed that public participation (the rights of neighbours and civic groupings to meaningfully object to planning applications that do not comply with the law) will, within a few weeks, be removed from all further development proposals, thereby giving the City the power to approve any development they wish with little or no concern to how this would effect the surrounding neighbours and the environment.


Currently, the various Subcouncils comprised of locally elected and PR politicians, are tasked with deciding on planning applications that require departures, consent use, etc. Although not perfect, it is at least democratic and passes constitutional muster. 

The amendment will now withdraw decision-making representation at local level – adding to Mayor de Lille’s summarily withdrawing of the SPELUM Committee’s (the committee tasked to decide environmental and policy related issues) decision-making powers last year. Currently, SPELUM can only make recommendations to the Mayoral committee, whose decisions, in turn, cannot be appealed. 


Not only will officials now be empowered to make unilateral decisions, those decisions may be premised on policy and not on law. There is a raft of case law from the various High Courts, especially the Western Cape, which has questioned the City’s use of policy rather than laws to make administrative decisions – and such decisions have routinely been set aside.


The Mayor is quietly attempting to push this amendment through a full sitting of Council scheduled for August whilst the DA caucus has effectively gagged dissenting councillors. All attempts by various civic/ratepayer groupings to properly consult with the DA in this matter have been met with a stony silence – other than the rather inadequate spin of Cllr Gareth Bloor, which has been published in the various broadsheets.


It is clear that the City is intent on fulfilling Premier Zille’s promise to developers to take their rather arduous task of personal financial reward from “red tape to red carpet”: And the consequences for long-term sustainability, the environment and constitutional rights will be sacrificed on the altar of political expediency.


The only option open to all citizens who value the freedoms of a liberal democracy and their right to effective participation in civic matters of concern to them, is to phone or e-mail your Ward councillor, the Mayor and their local DA office and demand that this amendment be struck from the agenda and consigned to the political scrap-heap of bad ideas.